Expert Mode - Insights from marketing, AI, and CX pros

Expert Mode: From Scarcity to Stewardship: Navigating the New Era of Software Abundance with Joe Cicman, Forrester

This article was based on the interview with Forrester’s Joe Cicman on what happens to enterprise SaaS when everyone’s making software? by Greg Kihlström, AI and MarTech keynote speaker for The Agile Brand with Greg Kihlström podcast. Listen to the original episode here:

For decades, the life of an enterprise marketing leader has been governed by a simple, often frustrating, economic reality: software is expensive, and getting it is hard. The process was a familiar gauntlet of business cases, budget approvals, procurement cycles, and political maneuvering. Every new tool in the MarTech stack represented a significant investment of time, capital, and organizational will. This scarcity, while limiting, also served as a natural governor. It forced a degree of discipline, compelling us to prioritize ruthlessly and ensure every decision had a defensible ROI. It was a constraint, but a predictable one.

That era is rapidly coming to a close. With the rise of generative AI and low-code platforms, the ability to create software is becoming democratized and, in some cases, trivial. The concept of “vibe coding”—spinning up a functional application with a simple prompt—has moved from science fiction to a daily reality for many. This shift from scarcity to abundance is more than just a technological evolution; it’s a seismic event that destabilizes the very foundation of how we think about our technology stacks. When anyone can create a tool, who decides which ones survive? When building is as easy as buying, how do you prevent your carefully curated ecosystem from devolving into a chaotic jungle of digital weeds? We spoke with Forrester’s Joe Cicman to explore this new landscape, where the primary challenge is no longer acquisition, but stewardship.

The Illusion of Unbounded Abundance

The central tension of this new era is the deceptive allure of infinite possibility. The old guardrails are gone. The economic and procedural friction that forced deliberation has been replaced by the frictionless ability to create on a whim. While this sounds like a marketer’s utopia, Cicman warns that it carries a significant, often hidden, cost. The absence of constraints can lead to a proliferation of redundant, unsupported, and strategically misaligned tools that create more complexity than value. The role of the leader, therefore, must evolve from being a procurer to a cultivator.

“There is this illusion that unbounded abundance is going to create value, and we found that it’s actually not. One of the governing metaphors we had as we were thinking through this keynote was, look, if you just throw seeds into the ground indiscriminately, the seed isn’t the magic. Any seed will grow. It will grow in soil. And you could grow weeds just as quickly as you could grow a real crop that’s gonna sustain. And so this idea of stewardship is to really put a very focused eye on anything in your organization that someone is making using AI to generate, and to ask yourself, ‘Is this a weed? Is this a crop that’s not gonna work, or is this actually the crop that is going to serve the marketing organization?’”

This metaphor of stewardship is a powerful re-framing for marketing leaders. It’s not about restricting creation, but about creating the right conditions for valuable things to grow. It means establishing a framework to evaluate these homegrown tools not just on their immediate utility, but on their long-term viability, their alignment with enterprise architecture, and their contribution to the overall business strategy. Is this new tool a temporary scaffold for a single campaign, or is it trying to be a permanent part of your architecture? Does it handle sensitive data? Does it integrate with core systems? Asking these questions transforms the leader from a simple gatekeeper into a strategic gardener, tending the ecosystem to ensure it produces a sustainable harvest rather than an unmanageable thicket.

Finding the “TAM of One”

With the lines between building and buying blurred, the critical question becomes: when should you do which? It’s tempting to think that if your team can build a “good enough” version of a CRM, they should. Cicman offers a brilliant heuristic to counter this impulse, derived from a client who encouraged widespread internal app development. After a year, the company had generated hundreds of custom applications, yet when they compared them to their existing SaaS portfolio, the overlap was almost zero. This led to a profound insight.

“As he looked at all of those other apps that people were making to do their job, he looked at those as a founder and he asked himself, ‘What is the TAM of that app?’ And what he discovered through that line of reasoning was the invisible hand of the market would never create a software company for a problem that one person had.”

This concept of the “Total Addressable Market of One” is the defining principle for the build vs. buy decision in the age of AI. Your teams should be empowered to create tools for hyper-specific, ephemeral, or deeply niche problems that no commercial vendor would ever find it profitable to solve. Need a tool to manage RSVPs for a single, unique executive event? Build it. Need a script to automate a repetitive task in a one-off campaign analysis? Vibe code it.

But this freedom comes with the responsibility of recognizing where the market’s invisible hand knows best. Building your own CDP is a fool’s errand. Replicating an enterprise identity and access management system is not just inefficient, it’s dangerous. Let Marc Benioff worry about being the best CRM provider in the world; your job is to be the best at what your company does. This framework allows leaders to foster innovation at the edges—where “TAM of one” problems live—while reinforcing the integrity and stability of the core, which should be powered by best-in-class, enterprise-grade solutions.

The SaaSpocalypse Is Not Coming

The rise of internal software development doesn’t spell the end for enterprise SaaS. It signals an evolution. Astute vendors understand they can’t compete with the sheer volume and specificity of internally-built tools. Instead of trying to build every conceivable feature, they are shifting their focus upward, transforming their platforms into orchestration and governance layers. They are building the chassis, not every individual component of the car.

“The investment has been on the coordination of all of that stuff on top. And so when I look at some of these companies, I will ask myself, are they building more tools that will sit behind an MCP server, or are they building the primitives that would be required for agentic coordination or orchestration? So, guardrails, governance, observability, those types of things.”

For marketing leaders, this means the criteria for selecting major platform partners are changing. It’s no longer just about the list of features a DXP or CDP offers today. It’s about the platform’s ability to act as a central nervous system for a hybrid ecosystem of bought, built, and legacy tools. Can it provide the “guardrails, governance, and observability” needed to manage this complex environment? This is why we see a convergence in the market, with DXPs, CDPs, and other platforms all racing to become that essential, agentic orchestration layer. Your most strategic technology decisions are now less about buying a tool and more about investing in the substrate that will coordinate all your other tools, regardless of their origin.

From Reimagining Work to Redesigning It

Ultimately, the most significant challenge isn’t technological; it’s organizational. Harnessing the power of software abundance requires a fundamental change in how marketing teams operate. Cicman argues that vague exhortations to “reimagine work” are insufficient. Leaders need to get their hands dirty and engage in the tactical, granular process of redesigning work. The problem is, many leaders don’t actually know the intricate details of how work gets done today.

“What I tell Forrester clients who have that question is not to reimagine work, but to redesign work… One of the challenges that I have observed is, with people bringing these, like, ‘Well, what does the work look like? What will the work look like?’ They don’t actually know what the work looks like today.”

Fortunately, marketing leaders already possess the exact mindset needed for this task. For years, you have obsessed over customer journeys, using analytics to map click-paths, identify points of friction, and optimize every step of the conversion funnel. Cicman’s advice is to turn that powerful analytical lens inward. Apply the principles of process mining to your own team’s workflows. Map the journey of a campaign from brief to launch. Instrument your internal processes just as you would your website. Where are the unnecessary “clicks”? Where are the bottlenecks? By identifying these friction points, you can strategically deploy custom-built AI tools not as random acts of creation, but as precise interventions designed to streamline a specific, well-understood workflow.

The transition from software scarcity to abundance is redefining the role of the enterprise marketing leader. The focus is shifting from procurement to stewardship, from feature acquisition to ecosystem orchestration. Success will no longer be measured by the size of your budget or the number of logos in your MarTech stack, but by your ability to cultivate a dynamic environment where both enterprise-grade platforms and hyper-specific, internally-built tools can coexist to drive business value.

This new world demands a leader who is part strategist, part architect, and part process engineer. By embracing the mindset of a gardener, understanding the “TAM of One,” and applying the familiar discipline of journey optimization to your own internal operations, you can move beyond simply managing technology. You can begin to truly design a more agile, effective, and resilient marketing organization ready for whatever comes next.

The Agile Brand Guide®
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.